The Latest Chapter on the Enforceability of Non-Compete Agreements in Illinois

New Illinois cases further muddy the waters for enforcement of non-compete agreements.

Last year we told you about the case of Fifield v. Premier Dealer Servs., Inc., 993 N.E.2d 938 (Ill. App. Ct. 1st Dist.2013), in which the Illinois Appellate Court for the First District held that, absent other adequate consideration, an at-will employee’s employment had to last for at least two years for it to be adequate consideration to support post-employment restrictive covenants.

But just when it appeared things were getting more clear as to the period of employment needed to support post-employment restrictive covenants, a Federal Court sitting in the Northern District of Illinois refused to follow what it saw as a mechanical approach enunciated in FifieldSee Montel Aetnastate, Inc. v. Miessen, 988 F.Supp. 2d 694 (N.D. Ill. 2014).  Declining to follow a two year rule of continuous employment enunciated in Fifield,  the Montel court elected to employ a fact-specific approach.

In the latest chapter of the subject, the Appellate Court sitting in the Third District followed the rule enunciated in Fifield that two or more years of continuous employment was necessary to constitute adequate consideration.  And, in that case, the court held that the restrictive covenant in question was unenforceable as the employee had tendered her resignation 15 months after the start of her at-will employment.  Prairie Rheumatology Associates, S.C. v. Maria Francis, D.O., 2014 IL App (3d) 140338 (December 11, 2014).

Call us today to verify whether your non-compete agreements are enforceable in light of the shifting sands of Illinois law.

 

If you liked this post, follow us on Facebook and Twitter sign up for our monthly newsletter using the form in the sidebar. And be sure to read the Disclaimer.

Charles Wentworth

Charles is an attorney in Glen Ellyn, Illinois.After graduating from the University of Utah, he clerked for Chief Justice John T. Broderick of the New Hampshire Supreme Court. He then became a litigation associate at Kirkland & Ellis LLP before opening his own office and partnering with Rick Lofgren. He lives just outside of Chicago, where he participates in community activities, including Boy Scouts and little-league baseball.
Charles Wentworth
Charles Wentworth
Charles Wentworth
Charles is an attorney in Glen Ellyn, Illinois. After graduating from the University of Utah, he clerked for Chief Justice John T. Broderick of the New Hampshire Supreme Court. He then became a litigation associate at Kirkland & Ellis LLP before opening his own office and partnering with Rick Lofgren. He lives just outside of Chicago, where he participates in community activities, including Boy Scouts and little-league baseball.